Discover The 3-Step System Helping Menopausal Women Drop Up to 3 Dress Sizes Sustainably

In this FREE Masterclass, I’ll share:
  • A common mistake women make when trying to resist cravings (and what to do instead)
  • Why busy women who want to fit better into their clothes should avoid hard exercise!
  • The surprising reason why discipline and willpower lead to short-term results and weight rebound
  • The hidden thoughts and beliefs that lead to self-sabotage
  • How to eat ANY food, enjoy meals out with friends AND lose weight

By signing up to this mailing list, you are agreeing to my Terms & Conditions. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Close

Why Personal Trainers Aren’t the Solution for Long-Term Weight Loss: A New Approach to Sustainable Change

Weight Loss Article

When most people decide they want to lose weight, their first instinct is to hire a personal trainer. While personal trainers can be helpful for achieving fitness goals, they may not be the best solution for long-term weight loss. Focusing solely on restrictive meal plans and intense workouts often leads to temporary results instead of sustainable change. In this post, we’ll explore why personal trainers might fall short for lasting weight loss and introduce a more practical approach that focuses on behavioural change and psychological shifts. Prefer to listen instead? Check out the full podcast here

console.log(‘foo’);

Prefer to listen instead? Check out the full podcast ‘Want to lose weight? DO NOT hire a Personal Trainer’ here

Why Personal Trainers Fall Short for Weight Loss

Many assume that hiring a personal trainer will solve their weight issues. However, while trainers are fitness experts, they often lack the tools to address the deeper psychological and behavioral factors contributing to weight gain. Personal trainers typically:

– Offer restrictive meal plans that don’t fit into your lifestyle.
– Focus on short-term goals like “losing weight for a holiday.”
– Overlook the psychological roots of overeating, stress-eating, and inconsistency.
– Rely heavily on willpower and motivation, which are often short-lived.

As Max, a former personal trainer, shared from his experience, many clients lose weight during their sessions but tend to gain it back afterward This cycle of short-term success followed by long-term disappointment can lead to frustration and a sense of failure.

The Importance of Addressing Root Causes

One of the biggest misconceptions about weight loss is that it’s purely about diet and exercise. Many believe that simply “eating less and moving more” will solve the problem. However, this only scratches the surface. For long-term weight loss, it’s essential to understand and address the deeper issues, which we call the Root Cause 5: emotional eating, negative self-talk, limiting beliefs, identity, and all-or-nothing thinking.

1. Emotional Eating: Many people turn to food as a way to cope with stress, boredom, or negative emotions. This habit often becomes ingrained over the years. Diets and meal plans don’t teach you how to manage these feelings in healthy ways. Instead, they often make things worse by fostering guilt when you “slip up.” Addressing emotional eating helps develop strategies to manage stress and triggers without relying on food.

2. Negative Self-Talk: The way you speak to yourself is crucial. Many women over 40 carry internalized negative messages about their bodies. Thoughts like “I’ll never be able to lose weight” or “I’m not good enough” can sabotage efforts from the start. This type of thinking becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. Our program focuses on changing self-criticism to self-compassion, building the belief that consistent progress is possible.

3. Limiting Beliefs: Tied closely to negative self-talk, limiting beliefs act as invisible barriers to success. Thoughts like “I’ve always been overweight, so I always will be” or “My metabolism is too slow” can prevent progress. The truth is, with the right approach, anyone can change. Our coaching helps clients identify and challenge these beliefs, breaking free from patterns that have held them back for years.

4. Identity: Your identity plays a significant role in your behaviour. If you’ve always seen yourself as someone who “struggles with weight” or isn’t “a fit person,” that identity will influence your actions. Achieving lasting change means shifting your identity to align with who you want to become. In our coaching, we help you rewrite your narrative and create a new, empowering identity. This new identity becomes the foundation for lasting weight loss and transformation because it aligns your actions with who you believe you are at your core.

5. All-or-Nothing Thinking: One of the biggest obstacles to lasting weight loss is the all-or-nothing mindset—the idea that you need to be perfect to succeed. If you slip up and eat something “bad,” you might feel like a failure and give up. We teach clients to focus on progress over perfection, emphasizing consistency over rigid perfectionism.

Iceberg image showing why you can't lose weight

Weight Loss Coaching vs. Personal Training: What’s the Difference?

When people want to lose weight, they often turn to personal trainers. However, there’s a key difference between personal trainers and weight loss coaches. Personal trainers typically focus on workouts, helping you build strength and achieve short-term fitness goals. They may offer restrictive meal plans with calorie or macro targets but rarely address deeper psychological factors.

On the other hand, a weight loss coach takes a holistic approach. They work with you to address emotional eating, stress, limiting beliefs, and mindset challenges. Weight loss coaching focuses on long-term behaviour change, creating sustainable habits that last a lifetime.

While personal trainers rely on willpower and motivation for short-term success, weight loss coaches help you change the way you think and behave around food and exercise, ensuring lasting results.

Real Transformation Stories: From Quick Fix to Lasting Change

Mollie, a coach at Live 360, shared her experience of working with a personal trainer before joining our program. Initially, she followed a restrictive plan and lost weight quickly for a holiday, only to gain it all back afterward. She blamed herself for the failure, but after joining Live 360, she realized the problem was the approach.

Through the Live 360 program, Mollie gained autonomy over her habits and made lasting changes that resulted in weight loss and transformed her mindset. Four weeks into the program, she noticed a shift—weight loss was no longer her primary focus. Instead, she felt empowered by the changes to her daily habits and how she thought about food.

Why You Should Think Twice Before Hiring a Personal Trainer for Weight Loss

While personal trainers can be helpful for fitness goals, they may not be the best option for those seeking long-term weight loss. Trainers often focus on short-term fixes and overlook the psychological and emotional factors that drive weight gain.

Before hiring a personal trainer, ask yourself:

– Do you want quick, temporary weight loss?

– Or do you want long-term, sustainable change that addresses the root causes of your weight struggles?

If you’re looking for lasting change, consider an approach like Live 360, which focuses on the deeper aspects of weight loss.

Ready to Make a Real Change?

If you’re tired of the diet cycle and feel like you’ve tried everything without success, it may be time for a new approach. At Live 360, we help women over 40 address the root causes of their weight struggles and achieve sustainable change.

Click here to learn more about how we help our clients.

You can follow 2 Meal Day on:

Instagram

Facebook

Twitter

YouTube